Bulgarian Air-Conditioning Producer Fined for Domain Infringement
Bulgaria’s Supreme Administrative Court (SAC) has recently upheld Bulgaria’s Commission for Protection of Competition (CPC) 2009 decision against a Sofia-based company for using a domain name confusingly similar to that of its competitor.
The legal proceedings were initiated by Ataro Klima, a producer of air-conditioning and ventilation equipment from Plovdiv, a town in central Bulgaria.
Ataro Klima argued that its competitor, Sofia-based Tangra AV, had registered and used domain www.ataro-klima.com (shut down in 2009), confusingly similar to its trade name and its own domain www.ataro.bg.
The CPC issued the decision against Tangra AV on the grounds of Article 35, Paragraph 3 of the Law on Protection of Competition. This provision prohibits the use of a domain name or website design identical or similar to those of other persons, in a manner that may mislead and/or injure the interests of competitors.
The CPC imposed a fine on the defendant in the amount of EUR 199,660 (USD 263,100), or two percent of the company’s 2008 turnover. The defendant appealed in August 2009 and in 2010, the SAC confirmed the infringement, but ruled that the amount of the imposed sanction was unjustified and instructed the CPC to reduce the fine.
According to the SAC instructions, the CPC reduced the fine to 19,960 EUR (26,310 USD) or 0.2 percent of the company’s 2008 turnover, and in 2012 the SAC upheld the CPC’s decision in its entirety.
Author: Valeri Penev
For more information, please contact Valeri Penev at our Bulgaria office.
Source: Bulgaria’s Supreme Administrative Court website
April 2012 News
- Amended Albanian Criminal Code Treats IP Infringement as Criminal Offense
- Ukraine Clarifies Practice Regarding Trademarks Containing INNs
- German Pet Food Manufacturer Wins Bad Faith Trademark Case against Serbian Company
- Bulgarian Air-Conditioning Producer Fined for Domain Infringement
- Heineken Wins Parallel Import Case in Russia
- SKYY Spirits Sues Russian PTO over Trademark Cancellation
- Serbian Red Pepper Chutney Registered as Appellation of Origin under Lisbon System
- HIPO and USPTO Make Patent Prosecution Highway Permanent
- Moldova and Eurasian Patent Organization Sign Cooperation Agreement
- Croatia IPO Director Becomes EPO’s New Vice President
- Slovenian Customs Seize 19 Million Counterfeit Items in 2011
- Macedonian Customs Seize Fake Sunglasses, Apparel, Mobile Phone Accessories
- Bulgarian Customs Seize Nike, Disney Counterfeits
- Counterfeit Alcohol 37 Percent of Russian Market
- Piracy Rates in Azerbaijan Sharply Declining
- 6,000 Counterfeit CDs Seized at Kiev’s Petrivka Market
- Unlicensed Software Seized in Bulgaria